Popular Articles
"Saltwater pool conversion" might sound like there is a lot involved. If you're wondering how you convert to salt, it really doesn't involve any big procedures. In fact, it's very DIY-friendly. If you can use some basic tools (or have a handy friend to help) you can do it yourself in about an hour.
Converting from chlorine to a saltwater pool simply means...
Read more
Once you start thinking about the pool again, many pool owners who still use chlorine ask themselves again if they should put a salt system on their pool, but don't know what to think about what they've heard. A very common question that comes up is "I've been thinking about changing my pool to saltwater, but I've just heard so many different things about it. Is it true that...
Read moreLatest Articles
Aftermarket Salt Cells vs. Original Salt Cells: Which is Better?
Content Table:
1. Best salt cells: Begin here
Before we embark on the journey of comparing genuine and generic salt cells (aka aftermarket cells), it's essential to grasp what a salt cell is and its pivotal role in your saltwater pool's health, especially if you are new to this because you have only recently performed a saltwater pool conversion. Central to any salt chlorination system, a salt cell is the key component that transforms salt into chlorine, essential for maintaining the cleanliness and safety of your saltwater pool.
In every salt system, from in-ground pools to above-ground salt water pool systems, the salt cell stands as a guardian, ensuring that the right amount of chlorine is consistently released into the water. This process is vital for keeping the pool free from harmful contaminants and algae, making the swimming experience safe and enjoyable.
When determining the best pool salt cell, pool owners are often faced with a crucial choice: opting for genuine original manufacturer equipment (OEM) cells, with their known quality and specific design guaranteed to be compatible with your salt chlorine generator, or considering generic / aftermarket salt cell replacements, often lauded for their cost-effectiveness but with variable quality in the marketplace. This decision is not just about the initial investment; it’s also about the long-term implications on your pool's chlorine output and overall maintenance.
As we delve deeper into this comparison, we aim to shed light on the best salt cells available, weighing the pros and cons of genuine versus generic options. Whether you're contemplating an aftermarket T15 salt cell or other generic replacement salt cells, this guide will provide the insights needed to make an informed decision for your saltwater pool system.
For more information, check out our comprehensive guide to salt chlorine generators.
2. Genuine salt cells: The assurance of quality and compatibility
When considering the upkeep of your salt chlorination system, opting for genuine cells is a decision that brings with it certain assurances. Genuine cells, specifically designed and manufactured by original equipment manufacturers (OEM), are tailored to fit and function seamlessly with your specific salt system.
Genuine cells defined
Genuine cells, often referred to as OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) cells, are exactly what their name implies – they are the original cells produced by the brand that made your salt chlorinator or salt water system. These cells are designed with precise specifications to ensure that you can easily restore the functionality of an existing salt chlorine generator and ensure it resumes operating with the same expected performance.
Genuine Salt Cells Available at Discount Salt Pool
Pros of genuine cells
Guaranteed fit and function: With genuine cells, pool owners are assured of a perfect fit. This eliminates the guesswork and potential compatibility issues that might arise with aftermarket options.
Assured reliability: These cells are often backed by extensive research and development, ensuring high reliability and performance. They are built to last and maintain consistent chlorine levels in your pool.
Manufacturer support and warranty: Opting for genuine cells often means you have access to the same level of manufacturer support as you did previously. This can often be a significant advantage in terms of customer service and peace of mind.
Cons of Genuine Cells
Higher cost: The major drawback of genuine cells is their cost. Being premium products, they are typically priced higher than their generic aftermarket counterparts. This can be a significant consideration for pool owners weighing cost versus benefits.
Genuine cells stand out for their guaranteed compatibility and reliability, making them a safe choice for those who prioritize assured performance and are willing to invest in quality. However, their higher cost can be a deterrent for some, leading them to explore aftermarket generic salt cell replacements as an alternative.
3. Aftermarket salt cells (generic cells): Balancing cost and quality
In the realm of salt chlorination systems, generic cells or aftermarket salt cells present an alternative to genuine cells, offering different benefits and considerations. These cells, often referred to as generic salt cell replacements or aftermarket salt cells, are designed to be a compatible alternative for various salt systems, but come from manufacturers other than the original equipment manufacturers (OEM); note that they are NOT made by or affiliated with the original equipment manufacturer and just sold under different labelling.
Aftermarket salt cells (generic cells) defined
Generic salt cells, more precisely labeled as aftermarket salt cell replacements, are produced by third-party companies. They are brand-specific in that they marketed as fitting and being able to work with select models of salt chlorination systems, including popular models like T15 salt cells. These cells are typically designed to fit and restore the function of an existing salt chlorine generator, but may incorporate different design elements or and be of varying quality & durability.
The range of quality of aftermarket cells can be considerable. There are many alternative aftermarket cells that are made with shorter lifespan titanium plates and sometimes different specs as the original. Some aftermarket cells may advertise long warranties, but that doesn't necessarily mean they are long lasting cells. Look closely at the cell's published specs - if the lifespan doesn't match the value of the lower price, it might not be a better value in the end. Most importantly, look up the aftermarket cell's brand on the Better Business Bureau and other review sites. Cells that are sold from overseas may not have US support and may or may not be able to actually provide effective support, no matter what how long of a warranty they have. At Discount Salt Pool, we offer a highly curated selection of aftermarket cells; we only offer aftermarket cell brands with a known track record of offering quality manufacturing and the support that is needed to stand behind the life of the product.
Aftermarket Salt Cells Available at Discount Salt Pool
Pros of aftermarket salt cells (generic cells)
Cost-effectiveness: The most apparent advantage of aftermarket salt cell replacements is their lower price point. They offer a more budget-friendly alternative to genuine cells, making them an attractive option for pool owners looking to reduce maintenance costs.
Cons of aftermarket salt cells (generic cells)
Possible difference in specs: While aftermarket cells are designed to be compatible with various systems, there's always a risk that it is not made to the same specs, which might affect the chlorine output and (more commonly) may not have the same lifespan titanium cells as your original saltwater pool system.
Variable quality: The quality of aftermarket cells can vary significantly between manufacturers. Research the reviews of any aftermarket cells you are considering - are people happy with owning them?
Variable level of support: Aftermarket cells may not offer the same level of manufacturer support, no matter what warranty coverage is claimed. Research the reviews of the brand or company that the aftermarket cell belongs to. A lack of support can pose significant challenges if issues arise post-installation.
In the spirit of transparency and objectivity, it's crucial to understand that while aftermarket salt cells offer certain advantages like cost savings, they also come with risks related to compatibility and quality variance. Our goal is to provide you with comprehensive, accurate information, enabling you to make an informed decision about whether an aftermarket salt cell replacement is the right choice for your saltwater pool. Most importantly, the brands of aftermarket cells we carry are carefully chosen because of their reputation and known level of quality.
For more information, check out our informational video on choosing an aftermarket salt cell:
4. Wrapping up: So, what are the best salt cells after all?
As we reach the conclusion of our detailed exploration into the world of salt cell replacements, the pivotal question remains: Once you’ve determined if your salt cell needs replacing, what are the best salt cells for your specific needs? The answer lies in balancing the various factors we've discussed, from cost to compatibility, longevity to performance.
For those prioritizing assured reliability, genuine cells stand out as the best choice. These cells are the default choice, specifically manufactured for your salt system, ensuring optimal chlorine output and a perfect fit. While they come with a higher price tag, the investment might be worthwhile for the peace of mind and manufacturer support they offer.
On the other hand, if cost-effectiveness is your primary concern, the aftermarket replacement salt cells could be the alternative path for you. These cells, if you've done your research and know the specs, quality, and level of support you should expect, can possibly provide a effective choice. However, it's essential to be mindful of the varying quality among aftermarket cells and to conduct thorough research of the brand, their reputation, and of other customer's reviews.
Its common that people in their words for things like what the best generic T15 salt cell is. As you can see, the best default choice is the OEM cell to avoid any unknowns. Ultimately, like anything else, the best salt cell replacement option depends on your individual requirements and objectives, as well as the specifics of your saltwater system. Whether you opt for a genuine cell or explore aftermarket salt cell replacements, ensure that your choice aligns with the needs of your pool maintenance routine, budget considerations, and long-term pool objectives. Remember, a well-chosen salt cell not only maintains the cleanliness and safety of your pool but also contributes to the overall enjoyment of your swimming experience.
Now that you know all about the best salt cells, perhaps you’d like to check our guide to installing a salt cell.
It wouldn't be right to say that there is any one best generic T15 salt cell - it involves considering factors like comparing your pool's needs, your budget, the specs of the cell, the brand's reputation, and actual customer reviews. If you're looking for an aftermarket alternative to replace a T15 type of cell, look for one that is known for its solid build quality, a lifespan that matches its cost, and positive user feedback. Researching and comparing different brands and models is key, as this will help you find a cell that offers the best balance between cost and performance. It's also wise to check for any additional features or technological enhancements that could benefit your specific salt water pool system.
The chlorine output is often close when compared between an aftermarket cell and a genuine cell, but it can vary. Genuine cells are specifically designed for to ensure the same level of chlorine output in accordance with the manufacturer's specifications for your salt chlorination system. Aftermarket cells may or may not always match these specifications; if the aftermarket cells' chlorine output is different, make sure it has more chlorine output than less.
To determine if an aftermarket salt cell replacement will fit your system, you need to check the specifications and compatibility information provided by the manufacturer of the aftermarket cell. Look in the product's description. If it doesn't specifically name your existing model of salt chlorine generator, it likely will not fit or be compatible. Only buy an aftermarket cell if it specifically is listed as fitting the chlorine generator model that you have.
When using aftermarket salt cells, regular monitoring of salt levels and chlorine output is crucial, as always. Ensure that the cell is cleaned regularly to prevent calcium buildup. Also, keep an eye on the control module of your salt water chlorinator to catch any error lights and address any pool problems early.
The initial cost of aftermarket salt cell replacements is typically lower than genuine cells, which can reduce upfront maintenance costs. However, research the lifespan of the aftermarket cell. If it is half the cost, but doesn't at least at last half as long as the genuine cell, that would lead to additional costs in the long run. Ideally, an aftermarket cell would last at least as proportionately as long (or more) than how much cheaper it is. Genuine cells, while more expensive initially, provide assured compatibility and performance.
The main risks of installing an aftermarket salt cell include variations in quality and lifespan, and possibly shorter warranty periods or even a lack of after-sales support if it is from an overseas or unknown company without the presence to stand behind the product. It’s important to thoroughly research and ensure that the aftermarket cell you choose is well-suited for your specific salt water pool systems. Discount Salt Pool provides a curated selection of aftermarket cells with known quality and known levels of support.
The frequency of salt cell replacement depends on the model, usage, pool sizing, and care as well as other factors. Genuine cells have a predictable lifespan based on manufacturer testing, with 10,000 hour cells being a benchmark that many popular models have (of course higher and lower lifespan models are available) Aftermarket cells may have different lifespans, especially if they use lower cost, lower quality components. Some low quality aftermarket cells have been found to have as little as 2,000 hour cells, though it would be more common to expect higher quality aftermarket cells to be in a range of 5,000 to 10,000 hours depending on the model. Regular inspection, proper use and maintenance are key to determining when replacement is necessary.
Switching back and forth between a genuine cell and an aftermarket salt cell should not present a problem, assuming the aftermarket cell’s compatibility if you use one. Each time you switch, be sure to follow the manufacturer's replacement instructions, including and resets required (if applicable) as well as verifying the pool's salinity level.
The long-term reliability and performance of aftermarket salt cells can vary. While some may offer performance comparable to that of genuine cells, others might fall short. It's important to research specs and customer reviews, and select high-quality aftermarket salt cells. Discount Salt Pool only carries aftermarket cells with known quality and known levels of support.
Tagged Products
Don't want to wait for this item? Here are some good alternatives:
- Aftermarket Model:
Generic IC20 Replacement Cell - Compatible New System:
SJ20 System (with Adapter Kit) - Compatible New System:
CORE15 System (with Adapter Kit) - Or, thinking about upgrading your system?Interactive Guide
Genuine OEM 3-Blade Replacement Salt Cell for the Saline Generating Systems Breeze 320 (now CMP) salt chlorine generator. 20,000 gallon max capacity.
- Aftermarket
Model:
Generic Breeze320 Replacement Cell - Comparable New System: CircuPool SJ20
- Comparable New System:
Autopilot ChlorSync CS30 - Or, thinking about upgrading your system?
Interactive Guide →
