Choosing the RIGHT Pool Cleaner: An Expert’s Guide

1. How to Choose the Right Pool Cleaner

Are you on the hunt for a new pool cleaner? While you may be used to pressure side or automatic suction pool cleaners, there’s a new crop of options on the market - including energy-efficient automatic robotic pool cleaners.

When looking for the best pool cleaner, there are many factors to consider, including the size and type of pool you have, maintenance, cost, and your goals for energy efficiency. But no need to worry! In this comprehensive guide, we'll navigate through the various types of pool cleaners, helping you make an informed decision that keeps your pool crystal clear all season long.

2. The Three Types of Pool Cleaners

When it comes to pool cleaners, there are three main types to choose from; suction side pool cleaners, pressure side pool cleaners, and automatic robot pool cleaners.

Until now, Suction side pool cleaners and pressure side cleaners have been the only choice for years, but there’s a new kid on the block! Similar to advances in home cleaning devices, there have been new advances in pool cleaning technology, and pool cleaning robots are quickly rising as the preferred choice for pool owners.

Suction side pool cleaners

Suction side pool cleaners have been around for several decades, and are considered a simple, affordable solution for cleaning the pool.

These cleaners are connected to your pool’s suction port or skimmer and are driven by the force of the water being pulled through them. As they move, they collect debris such as leaves, dirt, and small particles, which are then sucked into the pool's filtration system. Suction side pool vacuums are generally a less expensive option and require less maintenance because they have fewer moving parts.

However, suction pool cleaners impact the operation of the pool filter system which can both increase strain on the pump and increase energy usage. While suction side pool cleaners are great at removing fine dirt and debris, they may struggle with larger debris such as rocks, nuts, leaves, or branches, and can get hung up or only reach limited sections of the pool. This can even cause clogs and further strain your pool pump.

Pressure side pool cleaners

Unlike automatic suction side pool cleaners, pressure side cleaners are powered by the water pressure generated by the circulation pump, connecting to the return jet or a dedicated pressure line where the water flows back out to the pool.

These pool vacuums collect debris in an onboard filter bag or basket before it reaches the pool's filtration system, which means they are better equipped to handle larger debris, such as branches and leaves. They also help distribute water, which can be a benefit if you have a heated pool.

However, because they are powered by the pressure created by your pool pump, they use a lot of energy and typically require you to have a booster pump. Additionally, this means that if the pool is not already built for it, it can mean replumbing the pool - potentially costing thousands of dollars. Because they don’t follow a specific cleaning path, pressure side pool cleaners may miss corners or other tight areas, and if their pressure hose gets tangled, the pool cleaner can get hung up entirely. As a result, pressure side pool vacuum cleaners are also less efficient in collecting smaller debris such as sand, fine dirt, and leaves.

Robotic pool cleaners

A pool cleaning robot is an automatic pool vacuum that is a convenient, efficient choice for all types of pool owners. Not only do they vacuum and scrub the pool’s floors, walls, and even up over the waterline, but they do so intelligently to ensure maximum cleaning coverage.

These pool cleaners rely on their own power and filtration system, with models that simply plug into a standard GFCI outlet, with some even powered by a rechargeable battery. This means they are usually “drop-in” ready for almost any pool, and are extremely energy efficient. Pool cleaning robots are directed through intelligent technology, and with brushes and vacuum systems to scrub and suction dirt and debris, you can rely on them to thoroughly clean the entire surface of your pool.

Robot pool vacuum cleaners have their own filter cartridges and bags, preventing any debris or dirt from re-entering the pool water. And because of their highly efficient filters and independent operation, they help to reduce wear and tear on the rest of your pool equipment. They can even be programmed through Bluetooth devices or mobile apps to ensure your pool is cleaned exactly when and how you like it!

That being said, automatic robotic pool cleaners tend to have a higher upfront cost compared to other types of pool vacuum cleaners, such as suction side or pressure side cleaners.

Robotic Pool Cleaners Available at Discount Salt Pool

Robotic pool skimmers

When it comes to pool cleaners, another new choice is an automatic pool skimming robot. Automatic pool skimming robots provide cleaning coverage where almost all other types of pool cleaners can’t ever hope to go - across the top of the pool water where floating debris can stay.

Most robotic pool skimmers are solar-powered and work automatically to navigate the swimming pool’s surface, actively removing things like leaves, lawn clippings, bugs, and other floating debris.

If you have a swimming pool near trees or other vegetation, a robotic pool skimmer can be a life-saver!

Robotic Pool Skimmers Available at Discount Salt Pool

3. The Most Important Things to Consider When Buying a Pool Cleaner

Choosing the right automatic pool vacuum can feel daunting. Pool size, type, and shape, energy efficiency, price, maintenance, and even how often you use your pool - there are many things to consider.

By doing your research, you’ll avoid common mistakes and ensure you’re choosing the best pool vacuum to fit your needs.

Type of pool

The first thing to consider when selecting a pool vacuum cleaner is the type of pool you have. Pool cleaning robots are a great pick for almost any type of pool, while automatic suction pool cleaners and pressure side pool cleaners may not always be the best fit.

Above-ground vs. inground pools

Above-ground pools tend to be easier to clean because they are typically smaller, and have a simpler shape and flat bottom. If you’re looking for a less expensive option, you could consider an automatic suction pool cleaner.

Pressure side pool cleaners are often not well suited for above-ground pools but are efficient at picking up the large debris that is more common in inground pools. That being said, they may require a booster pump and the accompanying plumbing infrastructure to effectively clean your pool.

Pool cleaning robots are a great choice for both above-ground and inground pools because they have their own motors and filtration systems. Pool cleaning robots are also superior in picking up small and large debris.

Size

Automatic robotic pool cleaners are a great choice for any size pool. When it comes to pool cleaning robots, battery-powered models can offer the most sizing flexibility. It is important to consider cable length for corded models, as longer cables are needed for larger pools. In addition, for automatic pool vacuum cleaners, check the product specifications to find the maximum pool size it can clean.

Suction side pool vacuums are usually slower in operation and are not well suited for medium or larger-sized pools. For smaller pools, they can be an efficient and affordable choice. Pressure side pool vacuum cleaners are better suited for large pools, as they are good at picking up larger debris, and require a more powerful pool pump. That being said, pressure side pool cleaners will need to have a long enough feed hose to accommodate the pool’s size.

Shape

Don’t forget to consider shape when selecting an automatic pool vacuum cleaner! Does your pool have a simple round or rectangular design, or maybe a kidney or L-shaped design? Add in steps, raised drains, coves, or unique features, and you’ll find that a pool vacuum’s job isn’t as easy as you might think.

It’s important to choose a pool cleaner that can navigate any design. With advanced navigation systems, powerful motors, and cleaning capabilities, you can be confident that a pool cleaning robot will leave your pool sparkling clean, no matter the shape or design. Suction or pressure side pool cleaners may not be as adept at navigating irregular shapes, corners, or other unique aspects of a pool.

Type of surface

Vinyl or fiberglass, concrete or natural stone, tile or pebble tec - there are many types of pool surfaces. Matching the right pool vacuum cleaner to your pool surface makes cleaning easy and keeps your pool looking great!

Regardless of your pool’s surface, automatic pool cleaning robots once again top the list. With their strong scrubbing power, they’re the best choice for lifting algae, stains, and dirt, even from the most uneven textures. Robotic pool cleaners can operate on slick surfaces like fiberglass and tile, or rough surfaces like plaster or stone. In addition, their brushes are designed to be non-abrasive, so you don’t have to worry about them scratching vinyl liners or natural stone surfaces.

How effective the pool cleaner will be

Which pool vacuum cleaner will give you the best clean for your buck? Choosing the most effective automatic pool vacuum for your pool involves considering a few key things, like its coverage, the type of debris it can handle, how fast it works, and how powerful its suction is. You'll also want to consider the micron value of the pool vacuum cleaner’s filter for capturing even the tiniest bits of dirt.

Do you want an automatic pool vacuum cleaner that just tackles the floor, or do you want it to cover the steps, lower wall, or even the water line? You know your pool the best, so be sure to look past the obvious, and pick an automatic pool vacuum that will keep every part of your pool fresh and clean all summer long.

Most importantly, do you want a pool cleaner that helps clean some dirt, or has the best chance to get all the dirt? The randomized operation of pressure and suction cleaners leaves their cleaning coverage up to chance; the intelligence of robotic cleaners is designed to ensure the pool gets cleaned end-to-end.

Finally, consider how much time you want to spend worrying about the cleanliness of your pool. Having a fast, efficient pool cleaner is just one more reason why you should choose a robot pool cleaner for your pool.

Debris

When choosing a pool vacuum, first consider the surroundings. Do you have trees nearby? Or perhaps you live close to a beach, where the view is lovely, but the sand in the wind - not so much.

Some types of pool vacuums, such as automatic suction pool cleaners, struggle to pick up heavy debris, such as leaves and branches. Others have a hard time grabbing the tiny grains of sand that get stuck between tiles or pebble tec surfaces. If you have heavy debris, you’ll also want a pool cleaner that has its own canister, otherwise, you risk straining your pool’s filter.

Pool cleaning robots are ideal, thanks to their powerful suction and advanced cleaning technology. With high-powered suction and rotating brushes, they efficiently capture all debris, from leaves to fine particles, leaving your pool spotless. With their precision navigation system, you won’t have to worry about the nooks, crannies, or corners that may go neglected with other types of pool cleaners.

And if floating debris is your challenge, pool skimming robots are ideal - guarding the entire pool’s surface from any leaves or other floating debris that might try to invade your pool.

Speed and suction power

Depending on the size of your pool, suction side pool cleaners can take several hours to get the surface clean. Pressure side cleaners are speedier but often miss finer debris.

Pool cleaning robots give you the best of both worlds. On average, these automatic pool vacuums take 2-3 hours to clean a medium-sized pool, with some premium models cleaning in as little as one hour.

In addition, the suction power of a pool vacuum can be the difference between a sparkling pool and residual debris, which is less than ideal for when it’s time to take a swim. Suction power is typically measured in gallons per minute (GPM), and as the number goes up, the power does as well. Experts suggest that an automatic pool vacuum has a GMP rating of at least 70 for the most efficient cleaning.

Filter fineness and micron value

“Filter fineness” can be a confusing term. The finer the filter, the smaller the pores that it allows water to escape through. The best indicator of the effectiveness of an automatic pool vacuum cleaner’s filter is its micron value.

Debris and dirt size is measured in microns, and when selecting an automatic pool vacuum filter, the micron value refers to the size of particles that the filter can effectively capture. A lower micron value means the filter can capture smaller particles, while a higher micron value means it can only capture larger particles. A filter with a micron value of 100 may be sufficient if you typically only have larger debris, but for catching the tiniest bits of dirt, look for a pool cleaning robot with a filter that has a micron value between 20 and 50.

Price: Upfront and long-term

When choosing the best pool vacuum for your swimming pool, it's not just about the initial cost – you've got to think long-term too! At first, pool cleaning robots might seem pricier - ranging anywhere between $500 to over $1500, but they often end up being cheaper in the long run. That's because these types of pool vacuums are the best at cleaning and don't put much strain on your pool's pump and filter. Plus, pool cleaning robots are energy-efficient, costing as little as pennies a day to run, so they won't rack up your electricity bill.

On the other hand, suction side and pressure side cleaners might be cheaper upfront, but these types of pool vacuums can lead to higher long-term costs with more wear and tear on your pool's systems. For a pressure or suction cleaner to work, the pump has to be running at peak capacity; since pumps can be one of the highest users of energy in your home, operating these cleaners long term can create a significant cost. So, think about both the upfront price and the long-term savings when you're picking out a pool cleaner!

Energy efficiency

If you’re all about saving energy (and money!), the type of pool vacuum you choose can make a big difference.

Automatic robot pool cleaners are often considered the most energy-efficient option. Thanks to their built-in motors, they don’t have to rely on your pool’s filtration system. Additionally, pool cleaning robots are designed to operate on low-voltage power, further reducing energy usage. There are also rechargeable pool vacuums, giving you the benefit of both higher energy efficiency and the convenience of a cordless pool vacuum cleaner.

On the other hand, pressure side pool cleaners rely on your pool's pump, which can increase energy use, especially if they need to run for extended periods to clean your pool thoroughly.

And the difference isn’t small - in general, pressure side automatic suction pool vacuums use about 1500 watts to run, vs as little as 180 watts with a pool cleaning robot. That is an energy savings of about 82%!

Maintenance

When comparing types of pool cleaners, think about how much time, energy, and money you want to spend maintaining it.

All types of pool vacuums should be checked from time to time, as they may need adjustments or parts to keep them running at their best. The manufacturer’s instructions will give you more information on how to best care for your pool vacuum.

The biggest impact pool vacuums have is actually on the maintenance required for your pool overall. Because robotic models come with their own filters, you don't have to worry about cleaning your pool's filter as often. However, with a suction side cleaner, your pool’s filter will require more maintenance. Regular cleaning and backwashing are recommended, extra work you won’t have to worry about if you choose a pool cleaning robot!

Quality build and longevity

If you take good care of your automatic pool vacuum and choose a quality-built model, it can last for many years. Choose a reputable brand, known for quality parts and sturdy construction - even if the price tag is a little higher, it will be worth it in the long run.

With less wear and tear, and durable construction, automatic robotic pool cleaners can last 3-5 years - sometimes even longer with proper care and maintenance. They also don’t put as much stress on your pool’s filter and pump, lengthening the lifespan of your pool’s components overall.

Warranty

Lastly, when it comes to cost, don’t skip on a good warranty. Regardless of the type of pool vacuum, you want to ensure that if anything goes wrong, you are covered by the manufacturer.

With an automatic robot, you should look for a warranty of 2-3 years. A trusted pool supply company will ensure you have a quality pool vacuum cleaner with a warranty that keeps you protected against unexpected issues or costs.

What else should you consider?

Now that we have the most important factors covered, there are a few more things that can help you decide on the perfect pool cleaner. With helpful modern features like Bluetooth or WiFi connections and phone apps, to high-powered jets to pick up the hidden grime lurking in corners, pool cleaners aren’t what they used to be!

Remote controls and connectivity

Who could have imagined being able to control your pool cleaner with your phone? Some robot models now connect to smartphone apps, so you’re able to schedule the pool cleaner’s operation, select specialty cleaning modes, and get notifications when the pool vacuum has finished cleaning. In addition, for cordless pool vacuum cleaners, the app will alert you when the battery is low.

Other automatic pool cleaners come with WiFi and Bluetooth connectivity and remotes for added convenience.

Scrubbers

One popular feature that makes a difference in the pool cleaner is the number of scrub brushes it has, and how many are actively scrubbing. Some models will have just one wide scrub brush at the front, while others can have up to four on all four corners turning independently to multiply the cleaning action.

Power washing jets

Suction side and pressure side cleaners may be sufficient for a simple pool surface, but no matter which one you choose, it’s inevitable that some dirt will get missed.

To pick up fine dirt, silt, or sand hiding in the corners, choose an automatic robotic model with a power washing jet. Even algae is no match for high pressure automatic pool vacuums, and not only do they clean more thoroughly, but they get the job done faster too!

Cleaning cycles

Not all pool vacuum cleaners come with programmable cleaning cycles, but if you want flexibility on what is cleaned, when, and how, you may want to select an automatic pool vacuum that gives you different cycle options.

You can choose between floor only, or add in the walls and waterline, and even choose duration and frequency of cleaning. Especially if you don’t use your pool as frequently or you’re going on vacation, by programming cleaning cycles, you can ensure that your swimming pool stays sparkling clean even when you’re not around.

Now it’s time to choose!

We’ve considered many important factors to keep in mind when looking at types of pool vacuums - the type of pool you have, both upfront and long-term costs, efficiency, ease of use, and even some of the extra perks that come with modern pool vacuums!

All in all, when comparing options, it’s clear that pool cleaning robots top the list. With their advanced tech and powerful cleaning abilities, they’re best suited to keep your pool sparkling clean all summer long. They're also energy-efficient, easy to maintain, and built to last, making them a wise investment for any pool owner. And with bonus options like rechargeable pool vacuums, remote controls, and smartphone connectivity, managing your pool's cleanliness has never been more convenient.

So, if you're dreaming of a sparkling pool with minimal effort, an automatic robotic pool cleaner is the ultimate choice for a summer of relaxation and enjoyment.